State of Maharashtra v. Pradeep Yashwant Kokade (2024): Inordinate Delay in Execution of Death Sentence and Article 21
Date Published

Case Name: State of Maharashtra & Ors. v. Pradeep Yashwant Kokade & Anr.
Citation: 2024 INSC 947
Date of Judgment: 9 December 2024
Court: Supreme Court of India
Bench Strength: 3 Judges
Bench Composition: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah and Justice Augustine George Masih
Relevant Provision: Article 21 of the Constitution of India, 1950
Introduction
The Supreme Court of India, in State of Maharashtra v. Pradeep Yashwant Kokade (2024), examined the constitutional implications of an inordinate and unexplained delay in executing a death sentence. The judgment emphasised that the right to life and personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution does not end with the pronouncement of a death sentence but continues until its execution.
The Court held that an unexplained delay in processing mercy petitions and issuing execution warrants can violate the fundamental rights of death-row convicts. It also clarified that there is no fixed mathematical formula for determining whether a delay is excessive. The circumstances of each case must be considered.
This judgment is significant for judiciary aspirants as it explains the relationship between Article 21, mercy petitions, death penalty and the constitutional safeguards available to death-row prisoners.
Facts of the Case
The case originated from a criminal incident that occurred on 1 November 2007. A female employee working night shifts at a company was picked up from her residence by a cab driver, Purushottam Dasrath Borate, who was responsible for transporting her to her workplace.
Pradeep Yashwant Kokade was also involved in the crime. The victim was brutally murdered, and the post-mortem examination revealed multiple serious injuries, including skull and rib fractures. The medical evidence also established that she had been sexually assaulted before her death.
Following the investigation, both accused were arrested and tried before the Sessions Court in Pune. On 20 March 2012, the Sessions Court convicted them of serious offences, including murder, rape and criminal conspiracy, and awarded them the death penalty.
The Bombay High Court and subsequently the Supreme Court confirmed their death sentences, treating the matter as falling within the category of the rarest of rare cases.
After the death sentences attained finality, the convicts pursued the constitutional mercy petition process:
- On 10 July 2015, they submitted mercy petitions to the Governor of Maharashtra.
- On 29 March 2016, the Governor rejected their petitions.
- In June 2016, they submitted mercy petitions to the President of India.
- On 26 May 2017, the President rejected their mercy petitions.
- Subsequently, after several administrative communications, the Sessions Court, Pune, issued execution warrants on 10 April 2019.
The convicts challenged the execution warrants before the Bombay High Court through separate writ petitions. They raised several grounds, including:
- Inordinate and unexplained delay in executing the death sentence.
- Delay in deciding their mercy petitions by the Governor and the President.
- Alleged solitary confinement during the pendency of their appeals and mercy petitions.
- Illegal rejection of mercy petitions due to non-application of mind.
- Issuance of execution warrants without providing notice to the convicts or their family members.
On 29 July 2019, the Bombay High Court accepted their challenge and commuted their death sentences to imprisonment for a fixed period of 35 years. It also set aside the execution warrants.
Aggrieved by the High Court's decision, the State of Maharashtra approached the Supreme Court of India.
Also Check: Review Is Not a Second Appeal: DVC Case (2026)
Issues Before the Supreme Court
The Supreme Court primarily considered the following legal questions:
- Whether an inordinate and unexplained delay in executing a death sentence can constitute a violation of Article 21 of the Constitution.
- Whether delays in processing mercy petitions and issuing execution warrants can justify commuting a death sentence.
- Whether there is a fixed period beyond which a delay in executing a death sentence becomes unconstitutional.
- Whether the constitutional courts can examine the circumstances arising after the judicial confirmation of a death sentence.
Arguments of the Parties
State of Maharashtra's Arguments
The State challenged the Bombay High Court's decision to commute the death sentences. It argued that the delay in the execution process did not automatically justify commuting the punishment, particularly considering the seriousness and brutality of the offences.
The State also relied upon earlier Supreme Court decisions dealing with delays in executing death sentences and argued that the delay must be assessed in the context of the circumstances of the individual case.
Respondents' Arguments
The convicts argued that the prolonged and unexplained delay in processing their mercy petitions and issuing execution warrants had caused severe mental agony and psychological suffering.
They contended that the administrative authorities had failed to act promptly, resulting in an unconstitutional delay. Therefore, continuing with the execution of the death sentence would violate their fundamental rights under Article 21.
Supreme Court's Judgment and Observations
The Supreme Court upheld the Bombay High Court's decision and dismissed the State's challenge to the commutation of the death sentences.
The Court made the following important observations:
1. Article 21 Continues Until Execution of Sentence
The Supreme Court clarified that the protection guaranteed under Article 21 does not end with the pronouncement of a sentence by a court. It extends throughout the process of executing that sentence.
The Court recognised that keeping a prisoner under the constant threat of execution for an excessively long period can cause severe psychological suffering and adversely affect the prisoner's physical and mental well-being.
Therefore, an inordinate and unexplained delay attributable to circumstances beyond the prisoner's control may make the execution of a death sentence unconstitutional.
2. No Fixed Time Limit for Determining Inordinate Delay
The Court held that the expressions 'undue delay' and 'inordinate delay' cannot be interpreted by applying mathematical calculations.
There is no universal time limit within which every mercy petition must be decided or every death sentence must be executed. The determination depends upon the facts and circumstances of each individual case.
The Court emphasised that even a comparatively shorter delay may become constitutionally significant depending on the circumstances, while a longer period may require examination of its reasons and surrounding facts.
3. Delay at All Three Stages
The Supreme Court identified undue and unexplained delays at three important stages:
- Processing and forwarding the mercy petitions to the Governor of Maharashtra.
- Processing and forwarding the mercy petitions to the President of India.
- Issuing execution warrants by the Sessions Court, Pune.
The Court noted that the period between filing the mercy petitions before the Governor on 10 July 2015 and the issuance of execution warrants on 10 April 2019 was three years, eleven months and fourteen days.
Even after excluding the time actually taken by the constitutional authorities to decide the mercy petitions, the remaining delay exceeded three years.
The Court held that the cumulative effect of these delays violated the respondents' rights under Article 21.
4. Gravity of the Crime Cannot Justify Administrative Delay
The Supreme Court observed that the seriousness and brutality of an offence cannot be used as a justification for ignoring an inordinate delay in the execution process.
Although the rights of victims and the need for proper enforcement of criminal law are important, the executive authorities must perform their responsibilities promptly.
The Court clarified that victims do not have a vested right to insist upon the imposition of capital punishment. At the same time, administrative negligence cannot be allowed to undermine the proper implementation of judicial orders.
5. Responsibility of Executive Authorities and Sessions Courts
The Court emphasised that executive authorities must deal with mercy petitions of death-row prisoners promptly.
It also highlighted the responsibility of Sessions Courts to act proactively in issuing execution warrants after the death sentence becomes final and enforceable.
The Court issued directions to prevent administrative delays, including safeguards relating to notice before issuing execution warrants, communication of warrants to convicts, access to legal aid and a minimum gap of fifteen clear days between receipt of the warrant and actual execution.
The Court did not find it necessary to decide the separate controversy concerning solitary confinement because the commutation was upheld on the ground of inordinate and unexplained delay.
Relevant Legal Provision
Article 21 – Protection of Life and Personal Liberty
Article 21 of the Constitution of India provides:
"No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law."
The Supreme Court interpreted Article 21 to include protection against unnecessary mental suffering caused by prolonged and unexplained delays in executing a death sentence.
The judgment also reaffirmed that a death-row convict can approach the constitutional courts when an unreasonable delay affects their fundamental rights. The Supreme Court discussed its jurisdiction under Article 32, while the convicts had initially approached the High Court under Article 226.
Start your Civil Judge Exam Preparation with expert guidance, comprehensive study material, live classes and structured Judiciary Exam Preparation Courses at Aashayein Judiciary. Build strong legal concepts and prepare confidently for the Civil Judge Examination.
Final Verdict
The Supreme Court upheld the Bombay High Court's judgment commuting the death sentences of Pradeep Yashwant Kokade and Purushottam Dasrath Borate to imprisonment for a fixed period of 35 years.
The Court concluded that the administrative authorities had caused undue, unexplained and inordinate delays at all three stages of the execution process. These delays violated the fundamental rights of the convicts under Article 21.
The Court also issued directions to ensure that mercy petitions and execution warrants are processed without unnecessary administrative delays.
Significance of the Judgment for Judiciary Aspirants
State of Maharashtra v. Pradeep Yashwant Kokade (2024) is an important Supreme Court judgment for understanding the scope of Article 21 and constitutional safeguards relating to the death penalty.
The key legal principles established in this case are:
- Article 21 continues to protect a convict even after the confirmation of a death sentence.
- Inordinate and unexplained delays in executing a death sentence may justify its commutation.
- No fixed mathematical formula determines whether a delay is inordinate.
- Delays in processing mercy petitions and issuing execution warrants must be examined collectively.
- Administrative negligence cannot be justified merely by referring to the gravity of the offence.
- Constitutional courts can intervene when delays in the execution process violate fundamental rights.
Conclusion
The judgment in State of Maharashtra v. Pradeep Yashwant Kokade (2024) reinforces the importance of Article 21 in protecting human dignity and personal liberty, even in cases involving capital punishment.
The Supreme Court made it clear that the State must follow a fair, reasonable and timely procedure while implementing a death sentence. An unexplained delay caused by administrative authorities cannot be allowed to subject a prisoner to prolonged psychological suffering.
The decision is particularly relevant for judiciary aspirants preparing Constitutional Law, Fundamental Rights and landmark Supreme Court judgments.