-9.webp)
BCCI v. Cricket Association of Bihar (2015) 3 SCC 251 is an important Supreme Court judgment dealing with the constitutional status of the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI). The case clarified whether a private autonomous organisation performing significant public functions can be brought within the scope of judicial review under the Constitution of India.
The Supreme Court held that BCCI does not qualify as 'State' under Article 12 because it is not subject to deep and pervasive governmental control. However, its public functions make it amenable to the writ jurisdiction of High Courts under Article 226.
This judgment is particularly relevant for understanding constitutional law, judicial review, public duties and the distinction between Articles 12 and 226.
Background of the Case
The dispute originated from allegations of spot-fixing during the Indian Premier League (IPL) in 2013.
BCCI, the organisation responsible for regulating cricket in India, had introduced the IPL in 2007. In September 2008, it also amended Regulation 6.2.4 to exclude IPL and Champions League T20 from certain restrictions concerning commercial interests of administrators.
In April 2013, allegations of spot-fixing emerged, leading to investigations by Delhi Police. Subsequently, BCCI constituted a Probe Committee initially headed by Sanjay Jagdale along with two retired judges of the Madras High Court.
The Cricket Association of Bihar challenged the constitution of this committee before the Bombay High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution.
It sought an independent investigation, action against the IPL franchises Chennai Super Kings and Rajasthan Royals, and disciplinary proceedings against N. Srinivasan.
The Bombay High Court found that the constitution of the Probe Commission violated the applicable IPL operational rules. However, it declined to grant certain additional reliefs sought by the association.
The matter subsequently reached the Supreme Court of India.
Also Check: Loop Telecom v Union of India (2022): Section 65
Issues Before the Supreme Court
The principal constitutional questions were:
- Whether BCCI is 'State' within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India?
- Whether BCCI can be subjected to writ jurisdiction under Article 226 despite not being State under Article 12?
- Whether a private organisation performing public functions can be held accountable through judicial review?
Supreme Court Judgment and Key Observations
The Supreme Court delivered its judgment on 22 January 2015 and examined the nature of BCCI's authority and its relationship with the government.
A. BCCI is Not State Under Article 12
The Court held that BCCI does not fall within the definition of 'State' under Article 12.
For determining whether an organisation qualifies as an instrumentality or agency of the State, factors such as government ownership, financial assistance, administrative control and deep and pervasive governmental influence are considered.
Although BCCI exercises considerable control over cricket in India, it is an autonomous private organisation and does not function under the kind of governmental control required for classification as State.
Therefore, BCCI cannot be treated as an authority under Article 12 merely because of its importance in Indian cricket.
B. BCCI Performs Public Functions
The Court recognised that BCCI performs functions having a significant public character.
Its responsibilities include:
- Regulating and administering cricket in India.
- Organising national and international cricket tournaments.
- Selecting and controlling the Indian cricket team.
- Representing India in international cricket.
- Regulating players and affiliated cricket associations.
The Court observed that BCCI exercises substantial authority over cricket, which has considerable public importance.
Consequently, its private organisational status does not automatically exempt it from judicial accountability.
C. BCCI is Amenable to Article 226
One of the most important principles established by this judgment concerns the wider scope of Article 226.
The Supreme Court clarified that the jurisdiction of High Courts under Article 226 is wider than the definition of State under Article 12.
Article 226 empowers High Courts to issue writs not only against government authorities but also against any person or authority performing public duties.
Therefore, even though BCCI is not State under Article 12, it can be subjected to judicial review in matters concerning its public functions.
D. Public Functions Require Accountability
The Court emphasised that private bodies exercising public powers cannot act arbitrarily while discharging public duties.
Their actions must satisfy standards of fairness, transparency and non-arbitrariness.
Thus, BCCI's decisions relating to its public functions may be examined by constitutional courts under Article 226.
Difference Between Article 12 and Article 226
This distinction is the most important takeaway from the judgment.
Article 12 | Article 226 |
Defines the meaning of State | Provides writ jurisdiction to High Courts |
Forms part of Part III | Forms part of Part V and Part VI |
Identifies authorities against which Fundamental Rights can be enforced | Allows writs for Fundamental Rights and other legal purposes |
Certain private bodies may qualify if they satisfy the tests of State | Private bodies may be covered when performing public duties |
Key principle: Every organisation that is amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226 does not necessarily qualify as State under Article 12.
Important Case Laws Related to the Judgment
1. Zee Telefilms Ltd. v. Union of India (2005)
The Supreme Court held that BCCI was not an instrumentality or agency of the State under Article 12 because it did not satisfy the required tests of governmental control.
2. Ajay Hasia v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi (1981)
The Supreme Court explained the principles for determining whether a body is an instrumentality or agency of the government under Article 12.
3. Andi Mukta Sadguru v. V.R. Rudani (1989)
The Court held that writ jurisdiction under Article 226 can extend to private bodies performing public duties, even when they are not government authorities.
6. Significance of the Judgment for Judiciary Exams
The judgment is important for Constitutional Law and frequently relevant to questions concerning the scope of writ jurisdiction.
Important points to remember:
- BCCI is not 'State' under Article 12.
- BCCI performs significant public functions.
- BCCI is amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226 in matters involving public duties.
- Article 226 has a wider scope than Article 12.
- Private organisations performing public functions may be subject to judicial review.
Particulars | Details |
Case Name | BCCI v. Cricket Association of Bihar |
Citation | (2015) 3 SCC 251 |
Court | Supreme Court of India |
Judgment Date | 22 January 2015 |
Important Articles | Articles 12 and 226 |
Subject | Constitutional Law |
Main Principle | Writ jurisdiction over private bodies performing public functions |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1. Is BCCI a State under Article 12?
No. The Supreme Court held that BCCI is not State under Article 12 because it does not satisfy the test of deep and pervasive governmental control.
Q2. Can a writ petition be filed against BCCI?
Yes. BCCI is amenable to Article 226 in matters concerning the performance of its public functions.
Q3. Why is Article 226 wider than Article 12?
Article 12 defines State for Part III, whereas Article 226 empowers High Courts to issue writs to any person or authority for enforcement of Fundamental Rights and other legal rights.
Q4. Which case discussed BCCI's status under Article 12?
Zee Telefilms Ltd. v. Union of India (2005) and BCCI v. Cricket Association of Bihar (2015) are important decisions concerning BCCI's constitutional status.
Prepare smarter with the best judiciary coaching in India. Build strong legal concepts, practise mock tests, and learn with expert guidance.
Conclusion
The Supreme Court's decision in BCCI v. Cricket Association of Bihar (2015) clarified the constitutional accountability of private organisations performing public functions.
Although BCCI does not qualify as State under Article 12, its significant role in cricket administration makes it amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226.
The judgment reinforces the principle that an organisation cannot escape judicial scrutiny merely by claiming private or autonomous status when it performs public duties.
For judiciary aspirants, this case is essential for understanding the relationship between Articles 12 and 226, public functions and judicial review.

About Aashayein Team
Legal Expert
Start Your Journey
Join 50,000+ aspirants and get access to premium courses, study material, and expert guidance.
Enroll NowView All CoursesFree Resources
Newsletter
Get weekly updates on legal news, judgments, and exam tips.
%20(1).webp)
-30.webp)
